Luc Montagnier, Nobel-Winning Co-Discoverer of H.I.V., Dies at 89

[IceWizard]

Luc Montagnier,
Nobel-Winning Co-Discoverer of H.I.V.,
Dies at 89


He helped find the virus that causes AIDS,
fell into a feud over it and later turned controversial,
taking an anti-vaccine stance during the Covid-19 crisis.




Dr. Luc Montagnier in 1998.
In 1983, he and his team of researchers in Paris spotted
the culprit behind AIDS, a retrovirus that had
never been seen before.
Credit... Nancy Siesel/The New York Times



By Randi Hutter Epstein
Published Feb. 10, 2022
Updated Feb. 11, 2022



Luc Montagnier, a French virologist who shared a Nobel Prize in 2008 for discovering
the virus that causes AIDS, died on Tuesday in the Paris suburb of Neuilly-sur-Seine.
He was 89.

The town hall in Neuilly confirmed that a death certificate for Dr. Montagnier had
been filed there.

For all the glory that Dr. Montagnier earned in helping to discover the virus, today
known as H.I.V., in later years he distanced himself from colleagues by dabbling in
maverick experiments that challenged the basic tenets of science. Most recently he
was an outspoken opponent of coronavirus vaccines.

The discovery of H.I.V. began in Paris on Jan. 3, 1983. That was the day that Dr. Montagnier
(pronounced mon-tan-YAY), who directed the Viral Oncology Unit at the Pasteur Institute,
received a piece of lymph node that had been removed from a 33-year-old man with AIDS.

Dr. Willy Rozenbaum, the patient’s doctor, wanted the specimen to be examined by
Dr. Montagnier, an expert in retroviruses. At that point, AIDS, or acquired immune deficiency
syndrome, had no known cause, no diagnostic tests and no effective treatments. Many doctors,
though, suspected that the disease was triggered by a retrovirus, a kind of germ that slips
into the host cell’s DNA and takes control, in a reversal of the way viruses typically work;
hence the name retro.

From this sample Dr. Montagnier’s team spotted the culprit, a retrovirus that had never
been seen before. They named it L.A.V., for lymphadenopathy associated virus.

The Pasteur scientists, including Dr. Françoise Barré-Sinoussi, who later shared the Nobel with
Dr. Montagnier, reported their landmark finding in the May 20, 1983, issue of the journal Science,
concluding that further studies were necessary to prove L.A.V. caused AIDS.

The following year, the laboratory run by the American researcher Dr. Robert Gallo at the
National Institutes of Health, published four articles in one issue of Science confirming the
link between a retrovirus and AIDS. Dr. Gallo called his virus H.T.L.V.-III. There was some
initial confusion as to whether the Montagnier team and the Gallo team had found the same
virus or two different ones.

When the two samples were found to have come from the same patient, scientists questioned
whether Dr. Gallo had accidentally or deliberately got the virus from the Pasteur Institute.

And what had once been camaraderie between those two leading scientists exploded into a
global public feud, spilling out of scientific circles into the mainstream press. Arguments over
the true discoverer and patent rights stunned a public that, for the most part, had been
shielded from the fierce rivalries, petty jealousies and colossal egos in the research community
that can disrupt scientific progress.

Dr. Montagnier sued Dr. Gallo for using his discovery for a U.S. patent.
The suit was settled out of court, mediated by Jonas Salk, who had years earlier
been involved in a similar battle with Albert Sabin over the polio vaccine.




Dr. Montagnier in 1984 holding images of the virus found to cause AIDS.
The top one was discovered by an American team led by Dr. Robert Gallo;
the bottom one was detected by Dr. Montagnier’s team in Paris.
The samples were later found to have come from the same patient.
Credit...Associated Press



In 1986, the virus that causes AIDS, known by Americans as H.T.L.V.-III and the French
as L.A.V., was officially given one name, H.I.V., for human immunodeficiency virus.

The following year, with the dispute between the doctors still raging, President Ronald Reagan
and Prime Minister Jacques Chirac of France stepped into the fray by signing an agreement
to share patent royalties and proclaiming both scientists discoverers of the virus.

Dr. Montagnier and Dr. Gallo shared many prestigious awards, among them the 1986
Albert Lasker Medical Research Award, which honored Dr. Montagnier for discovering the virus
and Dr. Gallo for linking it to AIDS. And in 2002 they appeared to have resolved their rivalry
when they announced that they would work together to develop an AIDS vaccine.
Then came the announcement of the 2008 Nobel Prize for Medicine or Physiology.

Dr. Gallo had long been credited with linking H.I.V. to AIDS, but the Nobel Committee for
Physiology or Medicine singled out its discoverers, not him, in awarding half the prize jointly
to Dr. Montagnier and Dr. Barré-Sinoussi. (The other half was awarded to Dr. Harald zur Hausen
of Germany “for his discovery of human papilloma viruses causing cervical cancer.”)

The Nobel committee said it had no doubt “as to who had made the fundamental discoveries”
concerning H.I.V. Introducing the winners at the award ceremony in Sweden, Prof. Björn Vennström,
a committee member, said, “Never before had science advanced so quickly from finding the
disease-causing agent to anti-viral agents.”

In his acceptance speech, contrary to the views of other AIDS experts, Dr. Montagnier said
he believed that H.I.V. relied on other factors to spark full-blown disease. “H.I.V. ,” he said,
“is the main cause, but could also be helped by accomplices.” He was referring to other infections,
perhaps from bacteria, and a weakened immune system.

By then, AIDS-related illnesses had killed more than 25 million people and an estimated 33 million
were living with H.I.V.

After his work with H.I.V., Dr. Montagnier veered into nontraditional experiments, shocking and
infuriating many colleagues. One experiment, published in 2009 in a journal he founded, claimed
that DNA emitted electromagnetic radiation. He suggested that some bacterial DNA continued to
emit signals long after an infection had been cleared.

“He was always controversial, but I had the greatest respect for the team he assembled,”
said Donald P. Francis, who directed the AIDS laboratory at the U.S. Centers for Disease Control
and Prevention in the early days of the AIDS epidemic and who was one of the first scientists
to suggest that AIDS may be caused by an infectious agent.

In a 2010 interview with Science, Dr. Montagnier defended his theories about DNA, saying:
“It’s not quackery. These are real phenomena which deserve further study.” That same year,
he accepted a professorship at Jiao Tong University in Shanghai to investigate DNA emissions.
He stayed there for about two years before returning to Paris.

Dr. Montagnier set off another uproar among scientists when, speaking at a conference on
autism in 2012, he suggested that long-term antibiotics could be successful in treating that illness.

Last May, he added fuel to the spread of false information about Covid-19 vaccines by claiming,
in a French video, that vaccine programs were an “unacceptable mistake” because, he said,
vaccines could cause viral variants.

And in January, in an opinion article in The Wall Street Journal written with the Yale law professor
Jed Rubenfeld, he criticized President Biden’s vaccine mandates. The authors said it was “irrational,
legally indefensible and contrary to the public interest for the government to mandate vaccines
absent any evidence that the vaccines are effective in stopping the spread of the pathogen.”





Dr. Montagnier waved to protesting supporters in Milan, Italy, on Jan. 15
after giving a speech challenging the effectiveness of Covid-19 vaccines.
Credit...Luca Bruno/Associated Press



Mark Wainberg, who was president of the International AIDS Society, professor of medicine and
microbiology at McGill University in Montreal and director of AIDS research at the Jewish General
Hospital in that city, said in a 2014 interview for this obituary that “Montagnier was in the right
place at the right time,” referring to his Nobel-Prize winning research. (Dr. Wainberg died in 2017.)

But in speaking of Dr. Montagnier’s later work, he said, “The fact is that his scientific ideas have
not been considered credible by his peers nor have they stood the test of time.”

Luc Montagnier was born on Aug. 18, 1932, in Chabris, France, the only child of Antoine and
Marianne (Rousselet) Montagnier. His father was an accountant, and his mother was a homemaker.
He once told The International Herald Tribune that his father, who had a makeshift chemical laboratory
in the family’s garage, had inspired him to become a doctor so that he could
“explain the world through science.”

Dr. Montagnier earned degrees from the University of Poitiers and Paris as well as from the Sorbonne,
where he taught physiology. He worked at the Virus Unit of the Medical Research Council in London
from 1960 to 1963, and for a year at the Institute of Virology in Glasgow. He and a colleague there
discovered the first double-stranded RNA virus and a new way to culture cancer cells.

Dr. Montagnier returned to Paris to direct a laboratory at the Curie Institute and, in 1972, founded
and directed the Viral Oncology Unit at the Pasteur Institute, where he led the team that discovered
the virus that causes AIDS.

He married Dorothea Ackerman in 1961. They had two daughters, Anne-Marie and Francine,
and a son, Jean-Luc. Information about his survivors was not immediately available.



Aurelien Breeden contributed reporting from Paris.