Welcome, Guest
You have to register before you can post on our site.

Username
  

Password
  





Search Forums

(Advanced Search)

Forum Statistics
» Members: 2,795
» Latest member: kidwinj
» Forum threads: 7,059
» Forum posts: 123,415

Full Statistics

Latest Threads
Odds and Ends ... With So...
Forum: The Lounge
Last Post: IceWizard
11-13-2026, 01:20 AM
» Replies: 11
» Views: 3,022
Here are a couple I found
Forum: IOPList Suggested IOP's
Last Post: gujjernoran
11-12-2026, 08:26 PM
» Replies: 1
» Views: 750
www.MacroMass.COM.PH
Forum: IOPList (Approved & Recommended)
Last Post: Macro Mass
11-11-2026, 04:56 PM
» Replies: 3,854
» Views: 7,118,352
The Juke Box is OPEN
Forum: The Lounge
Last Post: Mr. HIND
11-09-2026, 08:03 AM
» Replies: 2,939
» Views: 1,646,452
MOVIES
Forum: The Lounge
Last Post: IceWizard
11-09-2026, 05:10 AM
» Replies: 147
» Views: 48,165
www.MacroMass.COM.PH
Forum: IOP Discounts, Offers & More
Last Post: Macro Mass
11-08-2026, 09:07 PM
» Replies: 143
» Views: 79,656
Humorous Smilies
Forum: The Lounge
Last Post: IceWizard
11-02-2026, 01:22 AM
» Replies: 4,936
» Views: 4,241,828
Deaths So Far (and it's j...
Forum: World News
Last Post: IceWizard
10-31-2026, 07:15 PM
» Replies: 51
» Views: 14,316
'Biscuit' the dog is late...
Forum: World News
Last Post: IceWizard
10-31-2026, 06:16 PM
» Replies: 0
» Views: 135
GAME - Change one word ga...
Forum: The Lounge
Last Post: IceWizard
10-15-2026, 05:21 AM
» Replies: 2,142
» Views: 1,009,759

 
  Malone v. The New York Times Company et al
Posted by: IceWizard - 04-08-2022, 06:49 PM - Forum: World News - No Replies



Malone v. The New York Times Company et al

A line has been crossed


Robert W Malone MD, MS


[Image: uudpMgU.png]
Older paper


From: Steven S. Biss,

Attorney At Law
300 West Main Street, Suite 102 Charlottesville, Virginia 22903

April 6, 2022

To: David E. McCraw

Senior Vice President & Deputy General Counsel The New York Times Company
620 Eighth Avenue
New York, New York 10018 mccrad@nytimes.com

(and) Davey Alba
dalba@bloomberg.net davey.alba@gmail.com

RE: Malone v. The New York Times Company et al.


Dear Mr. McCraw and Ms. Alba:

I represent Dr. Robert W. Malone in connection with his claims against
The New York Times Company (“NYT”), Davey Alba (“Alba”) and unknown
editors and publishers for defamation, defamation by implication and insulting words.

On April 3, 2022, NYT published an article on its website written by Alba,
entitled “The Latest Covid Misinformation Star Says He Invented the Vaccines”.

Expectedly, NYT and Alba repeatedly republished the Article via social media.
[See, e.g., hers Twitter Post 1 and her Twitter Post 2].

The Article contains false and defamatory statements of fact of or concerning
Dr. Malone, including:

1. The headline misrepresents that Dr. Malone is the
“Latest Covid Misinformation Star” and further states that “[e]ven
two years into the pandemic, new misinformation stars are being minted”;

2. The Article falsely accuses Dr. Malone of “spreading
unfounded claims about the vaccines and the virus”;

3. The Article falsely states that “in recent months, as the
coronavirus pandemic has persisted, he has taken up an entirely
different role: spreading misinformation about the virus and
vaccines on conservative programs”;

4. The Article misrepresents that “Dr. Malone joins medical
professionals and scientists, like Dr. Joseph Mercola and Dr. Judy Mikovits,
whose profiles have grown during the pandemic as they spread
misinformation about mask-wearing and convoluted conspiracy
theories about virus experts like Dr. Anthony Fauci”;

5. The Article misrepresents that “Dr. Malone has twisted
legitimate policy debates to use them as cover for continuing to
spread misinformation and to advance claims about the pandemic
that are demonstrably incorrect”;

6. “Robert Malone is exploiting the fact that data-driven
course correction is inherent to the scientific process to peddle
disinformation. It’s extraordinarily dishonest and morally bankrupt”.

The qualities disparaged by NYT and Alba – Dr. Malone’s honesty, veracity, integrity,
judgment, morals and ethics as a licensed medical doctor – are peculiarly valuable to
Dr. Malone and are absolutely necessary in the practice and profession of any medical
doctor. The Article ascribes to Dr. Malone conduct, characteristics and conditions,
including, without limitation, intent to deceive and defraud, misinformation, disinformation,
grifting and financial exploitation, that would adversely affect his fitness to be a
medical professional and to conduct the business of a medical doctor.

See, e.g., Goulmamine v. CVS Pharmacy, Inc., 138 F.Supp.3d 652, 659 (E.D. Va. 2015)
(that a physician has committed misconduct worthy of losing his license to practice medicine
or dispense controlled substances is sufficiently similar to suggesting an attorney has
committed conduct worthy of disbarment); Echtenkamp v. Loudoun County Public Schools,
263 F.Supp.2d 1043, 1064 (E.D. Va. 2003) (statements that “could be construed  either
imply or to state directly that plaintiff lacks integrity or is unfit for her profession” where actionable);
Carwile v. Richmond Newspapers, 196 Va. 1, 8, 82 S.E.2d 588 (1954) (“Every false and
unauthorized imputation, spoken, written, or printed which imputes to a business or
professional man conduct which tends to injure him in his business or profession is libelous
and actionable without allegation or proof of special damages.”).

In addition to the above false statements, the Article misrepresents Dr. Malone’s credentials,
role and achievements in the development of mRNA technology and vaccines:


7. The Article misrepresents that “[w]hile he was involved in some early research
into the technology, his role in its creation was minimal at best”; and

8. The Article misstates that “[t]he idea that he is the inventor of mRNA vaccines
is a totally false claim”.

Significantly, Dr. Malone offered to show Alba the evidence concerning his research
and invention of the mRNA technology, but Alba refused to review it.

NYT and Alba’s false statements were immediately understood to convey a
defamatory meaning about Dr. Malone, see, e.g.:


(“Recently @daveyalba wrote a profile on Robert Malone,
who is a lushly bearded, pro-COVID money vortex fueled
by his own self-aggrandizing mythology & anti-vaccine fantasies.
He profits from the suffering of others”);

(“Dr. Robert Malone says he helped invent mRNA vaccines
and has been wronged for decades. Now he’s spreading
unfounded claims about the vaccines and the virus”);

(“Not only does Dr. Malone embellish his credentials and
spread deadly misinformation, he also attacks his critics in
very dangerous ways”);

(“The first rule of COVID grifters: ‘Robert Malone is exploiting
the fact that data- driven course correction is inherent to the
scientific process to peddle disinformation. It’s extraordinarily
dishonest and morally bankrupt’”);

(“Robert Malone Spreads Falsehoods About Vaccines”);

(“Dr Robert Malone has leapt to prominence as one of the leading
voices spreading COVID-19 misinformation. He has done this on
the false claim that he ‘invented’ mRNA technology”);

(“this was a really great piece by @daveyalba about someone i
have been particularly curious about: Dr. Robert Malone, who
claims to be the inventor of the MRNA vaxx. Now, he spends
his time peddling misinfo about Covid & the vaxx”);

(“I wish the NYT would just come out and say he’s a liar rather
than ‘spreading misinformation”);

(“COVID-19 has been a godsend for conspiracy influencers,
who have seized the chance to spread confusion about the vaccine
no matter how many people they hurt”);

(“ There’s gold in them thar hills: Robert Malone, who styles
himself as the inventor of mRNA vaccines and has become a
major source of vaccine misinformation, makes at least $31,200
a month from Substack, plus frequent appearances on conservative TV”);

(“ Robert Malone is a liar and a fraud.
2. He did not ‘invent’ the vaccines.
3. What’s up with framing this fraud as a ‘star?’”)




NYT and Alba’s false and defamatory statements injured Dr. Malone’s reputation and business.
Dr. Malone’s reputation as a medical professional has been severely compromised.

Demand is hereby made for an immediate public retraction of the false and defamatory statements
in the Article, a written apology, and compensation for the presumed and actual damages suffered
by Dr. Malone, including the insult, pain, humiliation, embarrassment, mental suffering and
injury to his reputation.

In order to mitigate the damage you have caused, the retractions must prominently notify NYT’s
online advertisers, subscribers, and viewers, and NYT and Alba’s social media followers, that
NYT and Alba retract and withdraw the scandalous statements in the Article.

NYT and its agents are hereby on NOTICE that Dr. Malone contends that the statements in the Article
are false and defamatory. Nunes v. Lizza, 12 F. 4th 890, 901 (8th Cir. 2021) (“‘Republication of a
statement after the defendant has been notified that the plaintiff contends that it is false and
defamatory may be treated as evidence of reckless disregard.’ Restatement (Second) of
Torts § 580A cmt. d (Am. L. Inst. 1977). Lizza tweeted the article in November 2019 after
Nunes filed this lawsuit and denied the article’s implication. The pleaded facts are suggestive
enough to render it plausible that Lizza, at that point, engaged in ‘the purposeful avoidance
of the truth.’”). Demand is further made upon NYT and Alba to cease and desist from any
further publication and/or republication of the false and defamatory statements.

My client wishes to resolve this matter amicably and without litigation. If you refuse to take
the above action within 30 days of the date of this letter, or if the retractions are insufficient,
he intends to take appropriate legal action to protect his rights and interests.



Call or email me if you have any questions.

Yours very truly,

Steven S. Biss






[Image: lalq6r2.png]


Print this item

  Durham Asks Court to Compel Production From Clinton Campaign, DNC
Posted by: IceWizard - 04-07-2022, 09:53 PM - Forum: World News - No Replies

[Image: GHRwlz5.jpg]



Durham Asks Court to Compel Production
From Clinton Campaign, DNC




[Image: 66r3OEh.jpg]
John Durham speaks at a conference in New Haven, Conn., on Sept. 20, 2018.
(Courtesy of the U.S. Attorney's Office for the District of Connecticut)


By Zachary Stieber
April 7, 2022
Updated: April 7, 2022



Special counsel John Durham’s team on April 6 asked a federal judge to force Hillary Clinton’s
presidential campaign and two other parties to hand over documents they claim are protected
by attorney–client privilege.

The campaign, the Democratic National Committee (DNC), and research and intelligence firm
Fusion GPS appear to be withholding documents that aren’t actually protected by the privilege,
Durham’s team said in the filing, entered in the case against ex-Clinton lawyer Michael Sussmann.

Of the withheld materials, almost all “appear to lack any connection to actual or expected litigation
or the provision of legal advice,” prosecutors told U.S. District Judge Christopher Cooper,
an Obama appointee who is overseeing the case.

In fact, of the 1,455 documents being withheld by Fusion GPS, only 18 emails and attachments
are said to involve an attorney.

The Clinton campaign, the DNC, and Fusion didn’t respond to requests for comment.

The documents in question are being sought for the upcoming trial of Sussmann, who was charged
with lying to the FBI for going to a bureau lawyer in 2016 and falsely stating he didn’t hand over
unsubstantiated claims about then-candidate Donald Trump on behalf of a client.

The claims were compiled with funding from the campaign and the DNC by former British spy
Christopher Steele and Fusion GPS, which was founded by former reporters.

Sussmann and his lawyers have been pressing the judge to dismiss the case prior to trial,
arguing that the lie about not bringing the information on behalf of a client wasn’t material
to the information itself.

Attorney–client privilege protects many communications between a client and their lawyer.
Disclosure to third parties usually undercuts privilege claims.

In the new filing, Durham’s team pointed out that Fusion GPS co-founders Glenn Simpson and
Peter Fritsch penned a book published in 2019, which means even if a valid privilege did once
exist, it might have since been waived.

Prosecutors also noted that Fusion GPS operatives regularly communicated with reporters about
their work, resulting in several stories before the 2020 election and a spate of others after
voters hit the polls.

Further, the Clinton campaign (HFA) and the DNC have claimed privilege over communications
sent between Rodney Joffe, whom Sussmann was also representing at the time, and a
Fusion operative, “despite the fact that no one from either the DNC or HFA is copied on
certain of these communications,” prosecutors said.

The government subpoenaed information from the parties in 2021.

Fusion GPS was paid by the Democratic entities through Perkins Coie, a law firm.
The agreement was introduced as an exhibit in the case.

Many if not most of the actions taken by Fusion GPS employees “do not appear to have been a
necessary part of, or even related to” Perkins Coie’s legal advice to the campaign and the DNC,
Durham’s team said.

Prosecutors want to examine the communications in a private, in-camera setting “in order to
resolve these issues and ensure that only legitimately privileged and/or attorney work
product-protected communications and testimony be withheld from the otherwise admissible
evidence and testimony that is presented to the jury at trial.”


The trial is currently set to start on May 16.







[Image: qdor03C.png]


Print this item

  Opening Day
Posted by: TrayGold - 04-07-2022, 05:38 PM - Forum: The Lounge - Replies (2)

It's Opening Day at most MLB parks today.  I am missing my beloved Cubbies again.  For years I always made it for the first game of the season.  Always cold and sometimes snowing.   Wink  Are there any baseball fans that want to share some good memories of your teams? 



 




I was at this game!

Print this item

  Angry mom who confronted Adams on toddler mask mandate fired from city job
Posted by: IceWizard - 04-07-2022, 05:09 PM - Forum: World News - No Replies

[Image: l9KluQC.png]



Angry mom who confronted Adams on toddler mask mandate
fired from city job



By
Susan Edelman,
Haley Brown and
Gabrielle Fonrouge




The Big Apple mom who crashed Mayor Eric Adams’ press conference Monday to blast him over his
tot mask mandate was fired shortly afterward from her job at the city Law Department,
The Post has learned.

Daniela Jampel, who served as an assistant corporation counsel, learned she was canned less than
an hour after she confronted a caught-off-guard and apparently annoyed Adams over when he
would “unmask our toddlers.”

Jampel had publicly challenged the mayor at an unrelated event on LGBTQ issues — as Adams
stood in front of a podium banner that read, “Come to the city where you can say whatever you want.’’

“Three weeks ago, you told parents to trust you that you would unmask our toddlers,”
Jampel told the mayor.

“You stood right here, and you said that the masks would come off April 4.
That has not happened.”

As Jampel attempted to ask why, City Hall staffers tried to cut her off when they realized she
wasn’t a reporter, but Adams, seemingly miffed at the mom getting a question in, allowed her
to continue, although he told her she needed to “come to a conclusion.”



[Image: tTEYo2E.jpg]
Daniela Jampel, pictured with her daughters.
Twitter/Daniela Jampel


“Turn on your phone so you can get my answer correctly but come to a conclusion,”
he snipped.

Sources close to the matter said Jampel — a leading local critic of the toddler mask mandate
and pandemic school closures — was informed by email shortly after the presser that she was fired.

The Law Department’s spokesman confirmed to The Post that Jampel was terminated Monday,
although the rep said the decision to fire her was made “prior to today.



[Image: VPtsDxG.jpg]
Jampel was fired from her job at the city Law Department
after crashing Mayor Eric Adams’ press conference.
James Keivom



“We hold all of our employees to the highest professional standards. In public statements,
Ms. Jampel has made troubling claims about her work for the city Law Department. Based
on those statements, the decision had been made to terminate her prior to today,”
the spokesman said.

“Today’s events, however, which include her decision to lie to City Hall staff and state she
was a journalist at a press conference, demonstrate a disturbing lack of judgment and integrity.
As of today, she is no longer an employee of the Law Department.”

Jampel told The Post in a statement, “I am retaining counsel and will not litigate in the press.”



[Image: W3QiPUB.jpg]
Protesters demonstrating against toddler mask mandates gather
near City Hall on April 4, 2022.
James Keivom



The mother of three had been out on maternity leave for the past eight months while actively speaking
out against COVID-19 restrictions in Big Apple schools and is the co-founder of an advocacy group,
Keep NYC Schools Open.

A source familiar with the matter said Jampel appeared to be in good standing with her bosses as recently
as mid-February, when one of them approved her request for extended maternity leave.

The higher-up approved her request and said her colleagues were looking forward to working with her
again upon her return, the source added.

City sources say the decision to terminate Jampel came Friday after she wrote a tweet criticizing Adams
for upholding the toddler mask mandate and said her job with the city entailed defending
“cops who lie in court, teachers who molest children, prison guards who beat inmates.”



[Image: cn2gi68.jpg]
Mayor Eric Adams announced that children in day care and
early childhood settings would continue to wear face coverings.
Matthew McDermott



“It is a job I have done proudly. Until tonight. Fighting to keep masks on toddlers is shameful.
I am ashamed of my office,” Jampel wrote.

Monday’s press conference was not the first time Jampel spoke against COVID-19 restrictions,
but it was the first time she directly confronted Adams.

The ordeal came after Adams warned city staffers last seek that every single communication from
a public agency, even notices as benign as a tree-planting event, must first be approved by
City Hall before being released to the press — all part of an effort to control messaging by
his administration, Politico reported.

“What is imperative to know is, you are assigned to an agency under a commissioner, but you work
for me,” Adams told staffers during a Zoom call, the outlet reported, citing audio it obtained of the meeting.

“The commissioner leads an agency, but I lead the city. I’m the mayor of the city and all communications
that come through this city government is coming through my message.”

About two weeks ago, Jampel attended a rally against the toddler mask mandate and was quoted in
The Post criticizing Adams for “not following the science.

“This is making a mockery of the science. This is playing us for fools,’’ she said at the time.

“New York state recognizes the science. Everywhere else in New York state — 10 miles away in
Nassau County, 10 miles away in Westchester County — toddlers are allowed to take off their masks
along with their older brothers and sisters,’’ Jampel added



[Image: bbao41D.jpg]
Jampel, pictured with her husband Michael Schneid and her daughter.
Rachman, Chad



But “our mayor and our new health commissioner tell us it’s not safe for
toddlers to take off their masks.”

Last March, Jampel penned an op-ed for The Post demanding the city Department of Education
end remote learning and bring kids back to school, an issue that made its way into the
court system when parents filed suit against the city.

She called the city’s “two-case rule,” which required school buildings to shut down for
10 days if two cases are found within a week, “arbitrary” and wrote that continuous closures
were creating “misery and havoc for children.”

Jampel started working for the city Law Department in February 2016 and earned about
$52 an hour fighting “complex personal injury actions” filed against the Big Apple, including
against “toxic tort, motor vehicle, and alleged police misconduct,” according to her
LinkedIn profile and public records.




She graduated from Fordham University’s law school in 2008.




Additional reporting by David Meyer


Print this item

  BOMBSHELL: Biden FEC Nominee ADMITS Her Name Is On Legal Document Attesting ...
Posted by: IceWizard - 04-07-2022, 04:51 PM - Forum: World News - No Replies

[Image: rj85cZu.png]




BOMBSHELL:
Biden FEC Nominee ADMITS Her Name
Is On Legal Document Attesting Voting Machines Used
In GA ILLEGALLY SWITCHED VOTES From
One Candidate To Another [VIDEO]



By Patty McMurray
Published April 6, 2022 at 6:05pm



100 Percent Fed Up reports

For a year and a half, My Pillow CEO Mike Lindell has been called a liar, big box stores
like Kroger, Bed Bath & Beyond, Kohls, Wayfair, and others have dropped his products
from their stores over his claims that the voting machines in the 2020 election switched
the votes causing Joe Biden to win the election illegally.

MI Constitutional attorney Matt DePerno, who hasn’t given up on his legal battle in
Antrim County, MI, to prove voting machines have the ability to switch votes, has been
demonized by Democrats, including the current Attorney General Dana Nessel, who
Matt DePerno hopes to run against in the November 2022 election if he wins the
nomination of the MI Republican delegates.

Yet incredibly today, while testifying in front of the Senate Rules and Administration Committee,
FEC nominee Dara Lindenbaum, an election lawyer and former General Counsel to Stacey Abrams’
campaign, admitted to Senator Ted Cruz that she put her name on a legal document swearing
that voting machines illegally changed votes from one candidate to another.

Joe Biden chose the former General Counsel to Stacey Abrams’ campaign to replace retiring
Democratic Commissioner Steven Walther on the regulatory agency that
enforces U.S. campaign finance law.

en. Ted Cruz to Biden nominee to the FEC: “As an officer of the court, you were willing to put
your name on a legal pleading alleging that the machines used in Georgia in 2018 were switching
votes illegally from one candidate to another. Is that correct?” Dara Lindenbaum: “Yes”


Watch:


[Image: ewa4GI3.png]



Washington Free Beacon reports

President Joe Biden’s pick to serve on the Federal Election Commission is representing
Stacey Abrams’s nonprofit and Raphael Warnock’s church in a lawsuit that challenged the
validity of Georgia’s 2018 election due in part to the state’s use of “unreliable”
electronic voting machines.

In November 2018, election lawyer Dara Lindenbaum signed on to a federal legal complaint
on behalf of Abrams’s Fair Fight Action. The complaint challenged the constitutionality of
Georgia’s 2018 election, which saw Abrams lose to Republican governor Brian Kemp in a
race she never conceded. Warnock’s Ebenezer Baptist Church joined the suit in early 2019,
just months before the Democrat entered Georgia’s 2020 Senate race.

According to the complaint, the state of Georgia “grossly mismanaged” the election by depriving
“Georgia citizens, and particularly citizens of color, of their fundamental right to vote.” As a result,
the complaint said, Georgia’s election “violated the First, Fourteenth, and Fifteenth Amendments
to the United States Constitution.” The complaint also lamented the use of “insecure and unreliable”
electronic voting machines that “lack a paper trail” and thus “cannot be audited”—those machines
even “switched” votes from Abrams to Kemp, according to the complaint.

While the lawsuit remains active, Fair Fight and other plaintiffs amended the complaint in
December 2020 to remove many of its assertions detailing problematic voting machines.
The move came after former president Donald Trump said voting machine irregularities led
to his defeat against Biden.




Print this item

  Joe Biden’s Released Tax Returns Don’t Explain Millions In Income.
Posted by: IceWizard - 04-07-2022, 12:40 PM - Forum: World News - Replies (4)

[Image: joQ0nUd.jpg]




Joe Biden’s Released Tax Returns Don’t Explain Millions In Income.
Where Did It Come From?



BY: BOB ANDERSON
APRIL 06, 2022



[Image: exyyA2l.jpg]



The sources of President Joe Biden’s large income after he left his post
as vice president have never been detailed in his tax returns.





In the week prior to the presidential election,
I wrote a piece that asked the question, “Where Is Hunter Biden’s Money?” It was an important
question then, even more so now. Given the legacy media’s recent validation of Hunter’s laptop
that discussed a slice of equity planned for the “Big Guy” in a deal that involved an entity controlled
by the Chinese Communist Party (CCP), we should know if any money from it (or other foreign sources)
ended up in Joe Biden’s pocket, but we don’t.

Recall that despite then-presidential candidate Biden having bragged that he had released his
tax returns with what his team called “a historic level of transparency,” the truth is that he only
released his individual returns. Those returns provided no detail regarding the source of most of
his income, dollars that flowed to him and his wife Jill by way of S-corporations they set up shortly
after his departure from the office of vice president. Those entities, CelticCapri Corp (his) and
Giacoppa Corp (hers), contained more than $13 million of the $17 million the couple had reported
in income after Biden left office, most of it in the first year (2017).

The same media that ignored Hunter’s laptop has shown a complete incuriosity about these entities,
accepting the premise that Joe and Jill raked in $13 million from their book deal to generate their huge
increase in income. We simply don’t know if that’s true, though. What we do know is that their book
sales were dismal. 

Perhaps sensing smoke starting to build just before the election, USA Today published a “fact check”
piece that attempted to support that the Bidens earned “$15.6 million … from speaking fees and book
deals” in the years 2017 through 2019 and that “more than $10 million of that total income was profits
from Biden’s memoir ‘Promise Me, Dad’ and $3 million in profits from Jill Biden’s book.”

Follow the source link provided to that $10 million number, though, and you’ll end up at Joe Biden’s
campaign website with financial disclosure links to only their individual returns — no S-corporation
tax returns. So, in reality, readers were left with a smokescreen. (Now the financial disclosure links
for 2016, 2017, and 2018 have even been changed to connect to a Democratic National Committee
fundraising site via ActBlue rather than the tax documents.)

I noted back in 2020 that, “While (Joe Biden’s) financial disclosures reasonably support the $2.7 million
of net income reported by CelticCapri in 2018, a notable $8.7 million gap exists between its $9.5 million
net income in 2017 and the $809,709 of disclosed income in that year from book tour and related
speaking events. Since his disclosure covers only part of 2017, we lack the insight into other income
that may explain it.”

To that obvious question, the legacy press simply yawned. But it will become increasingly harder
for them to maintain a head-in-the-sand position as more information arises.

Senators Present Proof of CCP Connections
Sens. Chuck Grassley, R-Iowa, and Ron Johnson, R-Wisc., recently showed proof of payments from what
they said were CCP-controlled firms “that prove just how connected the Bidens were and how
compromised President Biden probably is.” An August 2017 wire receipt showed $100,000 sent from
CEFC Infrastructure Investment to Owasco, and a copy of a November 2017 check from CEFC Limited
revealed $1 million paid to Hudson West III, LLC. Both recipient entities were tied to the president’s son.

Did any of that money, or other overseas income, go to Joe or Jill? We would know if the president
provided a copy of their S-Corp. tax returns with all partner K-1’s that flowed through them. But the
only detail we have is aggregate numbers reported on the couple’s individual returns. 




[Image: idkfsbd.jpg]


2017




[Image: 2OycJ2T.jpg]



2018





As it stands, we’re left to trust USA Today that Jill grossed $3 million (royalties plus about $700,000
from speaking fees) for a book that sold only 7,000 copies in its first week, and that from that book
deal she netted more than $1 million in the two years prior to its release, but only $175,319 in the
year it was published (2019). It’s possible an advance was paid, but could a publisher have
justified that amount?



[Image: YyYJKoO.jpg]



2019




The Numbers Don’t Add Up

We are told that Joe netted $12.2 million (after expenses) in the same deal for a book that sold
300,000 copies. Excluding the $4.2 million earned from touring and speaking, that yields $8 million
of income that we are to assume came from book royalties (higher if we know his gross revenues
before expenses).

For analysis purposes, consider that his book had a retail price of $27 for hardcover and $18 for
paperback, and assume a reasonable mix of sales so the average price was $23 (with no discounting).
On 300,000 books sold, gross revenues would’ve been just under $7 million. As an author, Joe
would’ve likely received about 12 percent of that using a blended royalty rate (15 percent hardcover
and 7.5 percent paperback typical from publishers), yielding about $800,000 income. Round it
up to $1 million if you prefer. Double it. It’s still not close to $8 million.

Sure, he likely got an advance, but would a publisher have advanced that kind of money to an
author whose prior work, “Promises to Keep,” sold only 49,000 copies?

So many questions.



Release the Full Tax Returns

Rather than ask for proof of sources of income, the media has been stuck in a repeating cycle of reporting
about whether Joe and Jill underpaid payroll taxes. That’s a valid question, but it may miss the much
larger one: Where did all of that money come from after Biden left office?

To that end, tax returns are a valuable investigative source document. Since the days of Al Capone, the
rule has been clear: Don’t ever fail to pay taxes on any income, even if shady. It’s the easiest conviction
for a prosecutor. So it’s logical that all income would be reported, and for any potentially over the ethical
or legal line, an upstream S-Corporation would serve as the perfect mechanism to obscure it from view.

On a matter of this importance, all possibilities must be fairly considered until proof is established one
way or the other. The president may have completely valid sources for all of his income, and if so,
he should demonstrate it, particularly given the evidence of foreign money flowing through his son
and indirect references to himself.

In releasing Biden’s tax return last year, White House Press Secretary Jen Psaki commented that the
“release (of) the president’s tax returns … should be expected of all presidents.” Surely she would agree
this means the full set of documents.

If this question involved former President Donald Trump and one of his sons, The New York Times and
The Washington Post would already be howling for full disclosure, and they would be right to do so.
So perhaps they will join now in saying,
“Mr. President, please clear the air of all doubt — release your full tax returns.”






[Image: qbL6lWT.png]




Print this item

  Hunter Biden ‘Laptop From Hell’ Whistleblower Reveals 450 Gigabytes of ...
Posted by: IceWizard - 04-07-2022, 12:22 PM - Forum: World News - No Replies

[Image: rj85cZu.png]





Hunter Biden ‘Laptop From Hell’ Whistleblower Reveals
450 Gigabytes of DELETED Material Will Be Released Soon
Including Over 80,000 NEVER BEFORE SEEN Images and Videos



By Julian Conradson
Published April 6, 2022 at 6:45pm




[Image: SpDSQ6w.jpg]




The whistleblower who provided copies of the Hunter Biden laptop to several elected officials and
major news outlets in early 2021 claims that he has recovered ‘450 gigabytes of deleted material’
from the laptop that was previously unknown, including 80,000 images and videos and more than
120,000 archived emails, according to an exclusive report by the Daily Mail.

For the past two weeks, Jack Maxey – the former co-host of Steve Bannon’s WarRoom Podcast – has
been in Switzerland working with a “team of IT experts to analyze and recover the deleted files that
he and his colleagues found hidden away on Hunter’s hard drive.

They intend to publish the files online over the next few weeks in a searchable online database.




From The Daily Mail:

“For the past two weeks, Maxey has been in hiding in Zurich, Switzerland,
working with IT experts to dig out more data from the ‘laptop from hell’

He says he intends to post them all online in a database in the coming weeks

Maxey says he has found ‘450 gigabytes of erased material’ including 80,000
images and videos and more than 120,000 archived emails.”




Maxey has been ‘hiding out’ in Switzerland because he and his team fear retaliation from the Biden
regime. Ever since he came into possession of Hunter’s laptop, Maxey says that he has been constantly
harassed by the whole array of Federal alphabet law enforcement agencies.

Immediately after sharing the contents of the laptop publicly, the visits from federal agents began and
his associates began receiving strange phone calls, putting Maxey in fear of his life.



Maxey explained to The Daily Mail:

Maxey said that after contacting DailyMail.com about the laptop last year,
black suburban SUVs appeared outside his house, and former US intelligence
officer friends he shared copies with told him they received strange calls.

‘I showed this to a friend of mine in desperation in February [2021] because
nobody would listen to me. No news organizations would take it. In fact, the
very first major news organization to take it was the Daily Mail,’ he said.

‘Very dear friends of mine, the sharp tip of the spear, were making welfare
calls to me every day, basically to see if I was still alive.’





In order to avoid another round of intrusion by the Feds, Maxey left the US, choosing Switzerland because he
believes it will not interfere in any way with the work that needs to be done to bring Hunter’s crimes to light.




Maxey continued:

“I came here [to Switzerland] so that we could do a forensic examination
of Hunter’s laptop safely in a country that still respects human liberty and
the ideals of liberal democratic principles.

‘I do not believe this would have been possible inside the United States.
We had numerous attempts on us from trying to do things like this there.”





If Maxey has what he says he does, there will be hundreds of thousands of new files that have never been
seen before. If the already public portion of Hunter’s laptop from hell is any indication, it’s hard to imagine
what was bad enough to be deleted.

Either way, the Hunter Biden crime enterprise has gone on for far too long. The FBI, the DNC, the mainstream
media, and the DC Swamp have been in possession of the materials for years now, even before the
New York Post broke the story in the months leading up to the election. And they all failed in their duties,
something Maxey points out in closing.

According to him, and a lot of other Americans, the widescale coverup for the bagman of the
Biden Crime Family is nothing less than betrayal against the United States.




The FBI had this on the ninth of December 2019. I suppose the first person
betrayed was a sitting US president in an impeachment hearing, when the
FBI had the exculpatory evidence in their hands to have that end instantly,
and they did nothing.

The American people were utterly betrayed, because I guarantee you
that Joe Biden couldn’t run for dog catcher if the American people
knew about this laptop.”








Print this item

  The Alfa Bank Hoax Is Looking A Lot Like Crossfire Hurricane
Posted by: IceWizard - 04-06-2022, 02:20 PM - Forum: World News - No Replies

[Image: joQ0nUd.jpg]



The Alfa Bank Hoax Is Looking A Lot
Like Crossfire Hurricane




BY: MARGOT CLEVELAND
APRIL 04, 2022



[Image: Fx9WPQY.jpg]




If cybersecurity experts could trigger an investigation into Trump for political reasons,
they can prompt an investigation of anyone, for any reason.




A lawyer for former Hillary Clinton campaign attorney Michael Sussmann revealed last week that
federal agents never asked Sussmann the origin of the data he provided the FBI related to the
Alfa Bank hoax. Beyond highlighting the hackery of the Crossfire Hurricane team, this revelation
raises broader concerns about the cozy relationship between the government and private
cybersecurity experts.

On Thursday, Sussmann’s Latham and Watkins attorney Michael Bosworth pushed for the dismissal
of the special counsel’s criminal case. That case charged Sussmann with lying to former
FBI General Counsel James Baker when he provided Baker “white papers” and data ostensibly showing
a secret communications channel between the Trump organization and the Russia-connected Alfa Bank.
According to the indictment, Sussmann falsely claimed during his meeting with Baker that he was not
acting on behalf of a client, when in fact he was working for both the Clinton campaign and
tech executive Rodney Joffe.

During last week’s oral argument on Sussmann’s motion to dismiss, Bosworth posited that
Sussmann’s allegedly false statement was not “material” to the FBI—and thus not a crime—by
arguing that because the FBI never questioned Sussmann on the source of the Alfa Bank information,
it was irrelevant to the investigation.

Not once will the evidence show, Bosworth argued, that “anyone at the FBI ever asked Mr. Sussmann,
‘Hey, by the way, where did this information come from?’ No one asked. Not once. Ever.” Sussmann’s
attorney continued: “Regardless of who his clients were, if the source of his information was so critical
to the government’s investigation, if it mattered so much, you’d think at some point someone would
have said, ‘Hey, buddy, you provide this tip to the government.
Where did this stuff come from? Who gave it to you? Where did—how did they get it?”

Bosworth’s argument came in response to prosecutor Andrew DeFilippis’s assertion that the special
counsel’s office would “put on the stand at trial witnesses who will say that, when you’re analyzing
data, you don’t simply close your eyes to where the data came from and compare it to other data or
look for corroboration through other sources. The first thing any responsible forensic analysis will
ask is ‘Where was the data from?’”

Picking up on Bosworth’s argument, the court interrupted DeFilippis, asking: “If that’s the first thing
a responsible investigator would ask, then why would it matter whether Mr. Sussmann was there on
behalf of a client or not? Wouldn’t the natural question have been, ‘Where did this stuff come from?’”

DeFilippis responded that because the former FBI general counsel wrongly believed Sussmann had
come forward “as a good citizen,” that lulled Baker into accepting the data and white papers without
question. Sussmann’s attorney called that argument “nonsensical,” saying that, “if, as the special
counsel claims, the first question that investigators would ask is where did the data come from,
that’s the question that’s paramount.”

Bosworth then stressed that the FBI knew the data didn’t originate with Sussmann because he’s
“a lawyer” and isn’t “sitting on a pool of DNS data,” and because Baker testified repeatedly that
“Sussmann told him that the information originated with various cyber experts.” “At no point did
the FBI say, “Who are those experts? Can we talk to them? Where did they get it from?”
Bosworth continued. “So, the notion that Mr. Sussmann’s statement about a client somehow
affected the FBI’s willingness to ask the basic questions they ask in any case just doesn’t hold water,”
Sussmann’s attorney concluded.

Bosworth made an excellent point—actually two, as we will soon see—just not the winning point
he thought. The failure of the FBI to ask “the basic questions” about the data and white papers
Sussmann provided on the purported Trump-Alfa Bank secret communications speaks not of the
unimportance of that information, but of the incompetence (or political corruption) of the
Crossfire Hurricane team.



The Tips of Many Icebergs


The FBI’s glaring lack of curiosity concerning the source of the Alfa Bank “intel” mirrors in many
respects how the agents assigned to investigate Trump approached the Steele dossier. With
Christopher Steele’s supposed intel, the Crossfire Hurricane team undertook some steps to
identify Steele’s sources and to verify the information contained in the memoranda. Yet before
they were able to do either, the Department of Justice submitted a Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act
(FISA) application to the FISA court and obtained a warrant to surveil former Trump campaign
advisor Carter Page.

The DOJ later submitted three renewal applications to the FISA court, again relying heavily on
the Steele dossier, even though agents were unable to confirm any of the non-public “intel” of
relevance and after discovering numerous problems with Steele’s reporting. The Department
of Justice’s Office of Inspector General or OIG later found that the FISA applications targeting
Page contained 17 “significant inaccuracies and omissions.”

Soon after, the then-presiding judge of the FISA court, Rosemary Collyer, blasted the FBI for its
handling of the Page FISA applications. She also stressed “the frequency with which representations
made by FBI personnel turned out to be unsupported or contradicted by information in their
possession, and with which they withheld information detrimental to their case, calls into question
whether information contained in other FBI applications is reliable.”

The FISA abuse seen in the Page case exposed the DOJ and FBI’s sloppiness, disregard for the law,
incompetence, and political bias, casting doubt on the entire FISA process. Similarly, the revelation
last week that no one from the FBI asked Sussmann for the source of the Alfa Bank data and
whitepapers suggests these same problems broadly infect federal law enforcement and intelligence
agencies.



Relying on Obviously Suspect Information


With Steele, the feds believed the unbelievable in part because of Steele’s pedigree as a former
MI6 agent. Here the FBI relied unquestioningly on Sussmann and the data and white papers he
provided from “various cyber experts” to open an investigation into the supposed Alfa Bank-Trump
communications network.

While Sussmann’s attorney posited that the FBI unquestioningly accepted the data and white papers
because the source of the information was irrelevant, the more likely explanation is that the
law enforcement and intelligence communities worked regularly with Sussmann, tech companies,
and cyber experts, and placed unwavering trust in those sources.

Sussmann’s congressional testimony confirmed that he had “various contacts with members of
law enforcement and the intelligence community on behalf of a number of different clients” since
leaving the Department of Justice. He had served as “a prosecutor in the [DOJ’s] Computer Crime
and Intellectual Property Section” before joining Perkins Coie.

Sussmann likewise revealed in court filings that Joffe, “far from being a stranger to the FBI—was
someone with whom the FBI had a long-standing professional relationship of trust and who was
one of the world’s leading experts regarding the kinds of information that Mr. Sussmann provided
to the FBI.”


There’s a Whole Lot of This Going On


It was also not merely Sussmann and Joffe with whom the FBI and intelligence agencies held close
contact. Rather, documents obtained from right-to-know requests to Georgia Tech reveal extensive
coordination between the Department of Defense’s Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency
(DARPA), the FBI, and cybersecurity experts.

Some of this coordination came through private organizations such as Ops-Trust, a self-described
“highly vetted community of security professionals focused on the operational robustness, integrity,
and security of the Internet” that includes both law enforcement and private cybersecurity experts.
The National Cyber Forensics and Training Alliance, or NCFTA, likewise “facilitates collaboration
and information sharing between private industry, academia, and the law
enforcement/intelligence community” with the FBI having an agent “collocated” at the NCFTA.

Emails reviewed by The Federalist show regular communication between the FBI and members of
the NCFTA listserv discussing investigative matters, including requests by the FBI for
“law enforcement friendly contacts” at tech companies. No wonder, then, that the FBI was “lulled”
into opening an investigation into the supposed Trump-Alfa Bank connection based on Sussmann’s
word that the data and white papers originated with cyber experts.


Just Consider One Other Georgia Tech Researcher


While the documents publicly available remain limited mainly to those accessible from Georgia Tech,
that material still provides a glimpse at the deep connection between private cybersecurity experts
and members of federal law enforcement and intelligence agencies.

Emails show, for instance, that Manos Antonakakis, the Georgia Tech researcher who reviewed one of
the white papers Sussmann later provided to Baker, worked for years with FBI agents, communicated
with DARPA about various requests to assist with FBI or DOJ investigations, and provided analyses
used in various criminal matters. Antonakakis also provided an analysis for the federal government
of hackers believed to be working for the Russian military intelligence agency GRU, known publicly
by the nickname “Fancy Bear.”

Other documents show that as part of Antonakakis’ work with DARPA and the $17 million contract
awarded Georgia Tech researchers to “identify the virtual actors responsible for cyberattacks,
a technique known as ‘attribution,” Antonakakis conducted attribution analysis for the federal government,
including with data provided by Joffe.


A Situation Ripe for Setups


This collaboration between government entities and private cybersecurity experts is, as the
Wall Street Journal recently reported, of “enormous intelligence value” and “can help governments and
companies detect and counter cyberattacks.” The Journal’s coverage, however, missed the mark when
it then noted that “the monitoring of web traffic flow by government entities and private cybersecurity
experts” raises “privacy implications.”

This analysis missed the larger and more serious scandal: Individuals with wide access to sensitive
government and proprietary data can exploit that data to target a political opponent. They can draft
misleading “white papers,” present the data and white paper to the FBI and CIA with whom they hold
a trusted relationship, and thereby trigger a criminal (or national security) investigation.

The Sussmann indictment and other documents filed in his criminal case allege this exact scenario,
with one cyber expert called merely the “Originator” but since identified as April Lorenzen creating a
dataset purporting to show the Trump-Alfa Bank connection. She shared her data with Joffe, who
tasked Antonakakis, Dave Dagon, and employees working at technology companies connected to Joffe
“to mine Internet data to establish ‘an inference’ and ‘narrative’ tying then-candidate Trump to Russia.”


Apparently Fabricating Allegations Out of Spite


Joffe would later present to other researchers a “white paper” that purported to explain the basis for
the Trump-Alfa Bank theory, asking for their feedback. While Antonakakis did not support the paper
and thought it “was not great,” privately he told Joffe that while “a DNS expert would poke several
holes to this hypothesis (primarily around visibility,” “very smartly you do not talk about” that.
“That being said,” Antonakakis added, “I do not think even the top security (non-DNS) researcher
can refute your statements. Nice!”

Knowing the deficiencies in the white paper, Joffe nonetheless allegedly had Sussmann hand it off
to the FBI’s general counsel, which then triggered a federal investigation into the supposed
Trump-Alfa Bank connection. The Clinton campaign also pushed the Alfa Bank hoax to the media,
directing reporters to talk to Georgia Tech’s Dagon about the analysis.

Sussmann also presented a second set of data to the CIA that allegedly consisted of internet traffic
exploited by Joffe, Dagon, and Lorenzen related to, among other locales, the Trump Tower,
Donald Trump’s Central Park West apartment building, and the Executive Office of the President
of the United States. In providing this data to the CIA, the “trusted” Sussmann told agents, the data
“demonstrated that Trump and/or his associates were using supposedly rare, Russian-made [Yota]
wireless phones in the vicinity of the White House and other locations.”

Not only was there “no support for these allegations,” according to the special counsel, the data
provided to the CIA was cherry-picked to create the appearance of a Trump-Russia connection,
while additional data compiled by the researchers but not shared with the CIA conflicted with the
Yota cell phone theory.


Weaponizing National Security Against Political Targets


These allegations indicate that, as with the Steele dossier, politically motivated actors presented false
or misleading information to federal agents to prompt an investigation into Trump. As in the case of
Steele’s intel, the Crossfire Hurricane team took the data seriously, in part because it came from
supposedly trusted sources.

Just as the implications of the FISA abuse extended beyond Page’s case and raise concerns about the
entire FISA system, the implications of cybersecurity experts allegedly exploiting nonpublic internet
traffic to frame a political enemy reach beyond Trump. If cybersecurity experts could trigger an
investigation into Trump for political reasons, they can prompt an investigation of anyone, for any
reason. Maybe they already have.

Lorenzen, Dagon, Joffe, and Sussmann allegedly culled data to fit a narrative and possibly draft
misleading “white papers” that Sussmann, on behalf of Joffe, then presented to the FBI and CIA
for political ends. This destroys the public’s trust in cybersecurity experts. The FBI’s failure to ask
even the most basic questions when it received the data and unsigned “white papers” from
Sussmann renders them likewise suspect.

Yet Dagon’s attorney has the chutzpah to claim, as the Wall Street Journal put it, “that the
indictment of Mr. Sussmann would have a chilling effect on decades of constructive cooperation
between private cybersecurity researchers and government.” “Because the way the government
and Durham has handled this, the cybersecurity community now is afraid to take anything to
law enforcement,” Jody Westby told the paper. As a result, “the whole nation is at a higher risk level,”
Westby warned.

On this latter point, Westby is correct: Our nation is at higher risk of cyber-attack. But the blame
for that firmly lies with the cybersecurity experts who abused the great power entrusted to them
to hurt Trump.

It is not merely those who prepared the material or presented it to the FBI or CIA who hold
responsibility. Every cybersecurity expert who bolstered the Alfa Bank hoax, defended a theory
that a “DNS expert” could easily poke several holes in, refused to reveal those deficiencies,
failed to call out colleagues for abusing the government and public’s trust, and instead blamed
the special counsel’s office for revealing the sham, shares in the blame.

The work private cybersecurity experts do, and the help they provide the FBI and intelligence
agencies, is of vital importance to our country and its national security. It is precisely because
of this that the Alfa Bank and Yota cell phone hoaxes are so scandalous.








[Image: eWU3tAK.png]





Print this item

  Caffeine
Posted by: Grovedale - 04-06-2022, 10:41 AM - Forum: Diet And Supplements - Replies (21)

Apologies if this is an inane question. I'm just curious as to what our members think as there is a lot of experience with various substances and obviously caffeine is ubiquitous. 

I don't drink caffeine but I was thinking of starting for an energy boost in the morning. Is it really healthier to be caffeine free? Or does it not make much difference but has benefits of improving energy and cognition?

Just curious....

GD  Heart

Print this item

  Numerous Health Problems More Likely Because of COVID-19 Vaccines Than Coincidence...
Posted by: IceWizard - 04-05-2022, 09:58 PM - Forum: World News - No Replies

[Image: GHRwlz5.jpg]




[Image: MVfEmS1.jpg]
A pharmacist prepares a vaccine dose at a COVID-19 vaccination
site in New York on Feb. 24, 2021.
(AP Photo/Mary Altaffer)



Numerous Health Problems More Likely Because of
COVID-19 Vaccines Than Coincidence:
VAERS Data Analysis



By Petr Svab
April 3, 2022
Updated: April 5, 2022


Various health problems reported by people after receiving one of the COVID-19 vaccine
shots are more likely caused by the vaccines than being merely coincidental, according to
an analysis of data from the Vaccine Adverse Event Reporting System (VAERS).

VAERS has been flooded with more than 1 million reports of various health problems and
more than 21,000 death reports since the introduction of the vaccines in late 2020. Some
experts and public officials have downplayed the significance of the reports, noting that
just because a health problem occurs after getting the vaccine doesn’t mean the problem
was caused by it.

However, a deeper analysis of the data indicates that many of the adverse effects are more
than just a coincidence, according to Jessica Rose, a computational biologist who’s been
studying the data for at least nine months.

“The safety signals being thrown off in VAERS now are off the charts across the board,”
Rose told The Epoch Times.

There are multiple ways to parse the data in order to flesh out whether the causal link between
an adverse event and the vaccination is real or illusory. For example, multiple COVID-19 vaccines
come in two doses. A random adverse event unrelated to the vaccine should be dose-agnostic.
A stroke randomly coinciding with a vaccination shouldn’t be picky about which dose it was.

In the VAERS data, however, a number of the reported problems are dose-dependent.
Myocarditis in teenagers is reported several times more often after the second vaccine
dose than after the first dose. Following a vaccine booster shot, in contrast, the frequency
is significantly lower than after the first dose, Rose found.



[Image: s5boQwk.jpg]
A graph showing age against the absolute number of myocarditis reports
filed to VAERS according to doses 1, 2, and 3 of the COVID-19 vaccines.
(Jessica Rose)



Other researchers and health authorities have already acknowledged that the shots are
associated with an elevated risk of myocarditis, especially in teenage boys, although they
usually also say the risk is low.

Yet dose-dependency shows up in the VAERS data for other problems as well, including fainting
and dizziness, which are more common after the first dose.


[Image: zmJ01Ok.jpg]
A graph showing age against the absolute number of syncope (fainting) reports filed to
VAERS according to doses 1 and 2 of the COVID-19 vaccines.
(Jessica Rose)


Rose acknowledged that statistical analysis seldom provides definitive answers. For instance, there
could be some unknown factor that leads to more reports of unrelated health events after the first or
second vaccine dose. In her view, however, the data leans away from such a conclusion.

Previous research shows that the majority of VAERS reports are filed by medical staff, who shouldn’t
fail to report adverse events based on which dose is being administered. To Rose, it seems more likely
that if people suffer health problems after an injection of a novel substance and if the problems
substantially change between the first and the second shot, the substance probably had something to
do with it.

“In lieu of being able to explain this happening for any other reason, it satisfies the dose-response
point quite well, in my opinion
,” she said of the myocarditis results.

As for why the reports dropped after the vaccine “booster” shots, Rose said she hasn’t found a definitive
explanation. It could be that people who didn’t feel well after the first two shots would think twice
about getting more. As such, those most at risk for an adverse reaction would be less likely
to get the booster.

She arrived at the results after she evaluated the VAERS data from the perspective of the Bradford Hill
criteria—a set of nine questions that are used by epidemiologists to determine whether any given factor
is likely the cause of an observed health effect. She said she found evidence to answer all of the questions
positively.

Rose encountered resistance in the establishment science circles when she first tried to publicize her
analyses. Last year, right before her paper on VAERS myocarditis data was printed, the publisher pulled
the paper for unclear reasons.






[Image: xA0altA.png]





*************




[Image: GHRwlz5.jpg]



[Image: 13xIi97.jpg]
Syringes with Moderna's COVID-19 vaccine sit on a tray in a vaccination
center in London on Dec. 4, 2021.
(Daniel Leal/AFP via Getty Images)



Researcher Calls Out Censorship After Journal Pulls
COVID-19 Vaccine Adverse Events Analysis



By Petr Svab
January 19, 2022
Updated: January 20, 2022




Jessica Rose didn’t ask for any of this. She started to analyze data on adverse reactions
after COVID-19 vaccines simply as an exercise to master a new piece of software. But
she couldn’t ignore what she saw and decided to publish the results of her analysis.
The next thing she knew, she was in a “bizzarro world,” she told The Epoch Times.

A paper she co-authored based on her analysis was withdrawn by Elsevier, the company
publishing the academic journal that ran the article, under circumstances that raised
eyebrows among her colleagues. The publisher declined to comment on the matter.

Rose received her PhD in computational biology from the Bar-Ilan University in Israel.
After finishing her post-doctoral studies on molecular dynamics of certain proteins, she
was looking for a new challenge. Switching to a new statistical computing software,
she was looking for an interesting data set to sharpen her skills on. She picked the
Vaccine Adverse Event Reporting System (VAERS), a database of reports of health problems
that have occurred after a vaccination and may or may not have been caused by it.



[Image: RopWEqZ.jpg]
A nurse administers a CCP virus vaccine to a health and care staff member
at the NHS Louisa Jordan Hospital in Glasgow, Scotland, on Jan. 23, 2021.
(Jane Barlow/PA)



She said she wasn’t looking for anything in particular in the data.

“I don’t go in with questions,” she said.

What she found, however, was disturbing to her.

VAERS has been in place since 1990 to provide an early warning signal that there might be a
problem with a vaccine. Anybody can submit the reports, which are then checked for duplicates.
They are largely filed by health care personnel, based on previous research. Usually, there would
be around 40,000 reports a year, including several hundred deaths.

But with the introduction of the COVID-19 vaccines, VAERS reports went through the roof. By Jan. 7,
there were over a million reports, including more than 21,000 deaths. Other notable issues include
over 11,000 heart attacks, nearly 13,000 cases of Bell’s palsy, and over 25,000 cases of
myocarditis or pericarditis.

Rose found the data alarming, only to realize authorities and even some experts were
generally dismissing it.

“Clearly, there’s no concern [among these authorities and experts] for people who are suffering
adverse events
,” she said.

The usual arguments against the VAERS data have been that it’s unverified and unreliable.

Rose, however, sees such arguments as irrelevant—VAERS was never meant to provide definitive
answers, it’s meant to give early warning and, as she sees it, it’s doing just that.

“It’s emitting so many safety signals and they’re being ignored,” she said.



[Image: EtPLv3x.png]
A screenshot of the homepage of the Vaccine Adverse Event Reporting System (VAERS),
which is co-sponsored by the CDC, FDA, and HHS.
(Screenshot/The Epoch Times)



She teamed up with Peter McCullough, an internist, cardiologist, and epidemiologist, to write a paper on
VAERS reports of myocarditis in youth—an issue already acknowledged as a side effect of the vaccination,
though usually described as rare.

As of July 9, they found 559 VAERS reports of myocarditis, 97 among children ages 12–15. Some of them
may have been related to COVID itself, which can also cause heart problems, but there were too many
cases to dismiss the likelihood the vaccines were involved, according to the authors.

“Within 8 weeks of the public offering of COVID-19 products to the 12–15-year-old age group, we found
19 times the expected number of myocarditis cases in the vaccination volunteers over background
myocarditis rates for this age group
,” the paper said.

After two weeks, on Oct. 15, the paper disappeared from the publisher’s website, replaced by a notice
of “Temporary Removal.” Not only weren’t the authors told why, they weren’t informed at all,
according to Rose.

“It’s unprecedented in the eyes of all of my colleagues,” she said.

When they brought up the issue with the publisher, they were first told the paper was pulled because it
wasn’t “invited,” Rose said. That was shot down as irrelevant by McCullough, who threatened to sue for
breach of contract. The publisher then turned to its terms of use, saying it has the right to refuse any
paper for any reason.

It’s still not clear why the paper was pulled.


[Image: tgTWmmt.jpg]
Jessica Rose.
(Courtesy of Jessica Rose)



“I do apologise, but Elsevier cannot comment on this enquiry,” said Jonathan Davis, the publisher’s
communications officer, in an email to The Epoch Times.

In late November, the paper was replaced by a notice that the “article has been withdrawn at the
request of the author(s) and/or editor
.”

“It just feels like weird censorship that isn’t really justified,” Rose said.

The paper’s conclusions are not necessarily controversial. A recent Danish study concluded,
for example, an elevated risk of myocarditis for young people following the Moderna COVID vaccine.

It’s common, however, even for papers that examine potential issues with the vaccines to frame
their results in a way that still endorses vaccination.

“That’s what you have to say to get your work published these days,” Rose said.

Her paper did no such thing.

“As part of any risk/benefit analysis which must be completed in the context of experimental products,
the points herein must be considered before a decision can be made pertaining to agreeing to 2-dose
injections of these experimental COVID-19 products, especially into children and by no means, should
parental consent be waived under any circumstances to avoid children volunteering for injections with
products that do not have proven safety or efficacy
,” the paper said.

The paper also called the vaccines “injectable biological products”—a reference to the fact that they
are distinct from all other traditional vaccines.

A traditional vaccine uses “whole live or attenuated pathogens” while the COVID vaccines use
“mRNA in lipid nanoparticles,” Rose explained via email. She said the lipid nanoparticles include
“cationic lipids which are highly toxic.” Pfizer, the manufacturer of the most popular COVID-19 vaccine
in many countries, addressed the issue by saying the dose is sufficiently low to ensure “an acceptable
safety margin
,” according to the European drug authority,
the Committee for Medicinal Products for Human Use (pdf).

Rose also noted that the COVID-19 vaccines haven’t gone “through the 10-15 years of safety testing
that vaccines have always had to go through … for obvious reasons
.”

By this point, Rose is no longer a dispassionate observer. Reading through countless VAERS reports
gave her a window into the hardships of those who believe they’ve been harmed by the vaccines.

“I speak for all of those people,” she said.



[Image: o6kUv8J.jpg]
An internal medicine resident sits in a waiting area before receiving a dose of the
Pfizer-BioNTech COVID-19 vaccine at a hospital in Aurora, Colorado, on Dec. 16, 2020.
(Michael Ciaglo/Getty Images)



In the past, 50 reports of deaths in VAERS would prompt authorities to hit the brakes and investigate,
Rose said. In her view, that should have happened with the COVID-19 vaccines a year ago.

Not only has that not happened, but it isn’t even clear what would be enough to convince the
authorities to do so.

“What’s the cut-off number for the number of deaths?” Rose asked.

The counterargument is that the vaccines save more lives than they cost. But in Rose’s view, this logic
is flawed since the vaccines haven’t been around long enough and studied thoroughly enough to tell
how many lives they may cost.

It is known, however, that VAERS understates adverse events following vaccination—by a factor of
anywhere between 5 and as much as 100, based on some estimates.

Submitting a VAERS report takes about 30 minutes and many medical practitioners simply don’t have
the time, Rose said. Some may feel that filing the report may get them labeled as “anti-vaxxers.”
Some may simply not associate whatever health issue they’re facing with the vaccination.
Some may not even be aware VAERS exists.

It’s unlikely that any significant number of the reports would be fraudulent, she suggested,
noting it’s a federal offense to submit a false report.

Rose has now joined the ranks of dissident doctors and researchers skeptical of the official line
on the vaccines and the pandemic in general. She described it as something she’s compelled to
do despite the disincentives involved.

“We don’t want to be doing this. But it is our duty. Doctors swore an oath to do no harm.
And researchers with integrity cannot look away from this
,” she said via email.





[Image: xA0altA.png]



Print this item