EVERY AMERICAN EVER CONVICTED OF TREASON
(AND WHAT HAPPENED NEXT)
![[Image: cRMSD0m.jpg]](https://i.imgur.com/cRMSD0m.jpg)
BY MORRIS M.
MARCH 7, 2019 11:59 AM EDT
It's a word you're guaranteed to hear flooding the airwaves every time a president signs an
unpopular bill or a congressperson comes out against bombing some remote nation: "Treason!"
But despite what talk radio might have you believe, treason ain't treason in the U.S. unless it
meets some specific criteria. Per the Constitution: "Treason against the United States, shall
consist only in levying war against them, or in adhering to their enemies, giving them aid and
comfort. No person shall be convicted of treason unless on the testimony of two witnesses to
the same overt act, or on confession in open court." That's pretty precise language, so it should
come as no surprise that almost no one has been convicted of treason in U.S. history.
That being said, "almost no one" isn't the same as plain ol' "no one." In the 2.5-ish centuries
America has existed as an independent state, a handful of people have managed to do a
Benedict Arnold and had it proved in court. Some you probably know. Some — like Ethel and
Julius Rosenberg, who were actually convicted of espionage and not treason — you only think
you know. The rest you're about to find out about.
JOHN MITCHELL AND PHILIP WEIGEL'S DUBIOUS FIRST
The U.S. Constitution was only ratified in 1788, but before a decade was out two men had already
succeeded in hitting its strict criteria for treason. John Mitchell and Philip Weigel were whiskey distillers
who'd been thrilled when the United States came into being ... only to watch in horror as one of
Congress' very first acts was to hit them with a gigantic tax. Having just, y'know, fought a war
against unfair taxes, the distillers not unreasonably assumed the Founding Fathers should practice
what they preached. And so began the Whiskey Rebellion, a period of civil unrest that lasted from
1791-95 and saw buildings torched, homes attacked, and at least one tax collector tarred and
feathered (via Smithsonian).
After Alexander Hamilton crushed the rebellion, some 150 men were arrested, but only Mitchell and
Weigel were unlucky enough to have the necessary two witnesses willing to testify against them on
treason charges. They were sentenced to hang, although both received presidential pardons from
George Washington, who perhaps recognized the irony of a nation founded on a tax rebellion executing
two men for rebelling against what they felt was unfair taxation.
JOHN FRIES' VIOLENCE FREE REBELLION
As rebellions go, John Fries' 1799 attempt was almost painfully ineffective. In 1798, the administration
of John Adams (above) decided to hike up taxes on everything, having evidently learned no lessons from
the Whiskey Rebellion just four years before. The farmers of eastern Pennsylvania took this particularly
badly, formed into armed gangs under the leadership of John Fries, and intimidated local jails into
releasing all tax evaders. Adams responded by sending in the troops, Fries was arrested without incident,
and that was that.
At least, that was it for the rebellion that carried his name. As Britannica describes, Fries himself was
convicted of treason and sentenced to hang. He was actually convicted twice and sentenced to hang,
which would have made for an uncomfortable spectacle if they'd tried to hang him a second time.
Thankfully, Pennsylvania was spared the sight of the federal government trying to hang a dead man in
April 1800 when Adams pulled a Washington and pardoned Fries.
THOMAS DORR'S ONE-MAN CIVIL WAR
In 1842, Rhode Island had a problem. Nope, not its needlessly diminutive stature, but that it had two
governments. The year before, a people's assembly had been called and a constitution written for the state,
which until that point hadn't had one. Unfortunately, the elites in charge refused to recognize the new
constitution, so the 1842 election was fought twice, by two sides running under different laws.
Samuel Ward King won under the old laws, while Thomas Dorr won under the new constitution.
When Rhode Island's government recognized King's victory, Dorr responded by going to war
(via New England Today).
Dorr had no military training, and no access to weapons. Still, he scrambled enough men to steal two
cannons. He then tried to attack the city arsenal in Providence, only for the stolen cannons to malfunction.
Embarrassed, Dorr fled into the night and was arrested and sentenced to life in prison for treason
against his state. Not that he served anything like it. His crazy "war" defending the constitution earned
him so much respect in Rhode Island that he was freed in 1845.
JOHN BROWN FIRES THE STARTING GUN ON THE CIVIL WAR
John Brown was a guy who hated the concept of slavery, to the extent that he once assassinated
five random pro-slavery settlers in Kansas to try and balance the books. By 1858, he was openly
planning to spark an insurrection among slaves in the South to force the issue of abolition through
bullets and bloodshed. In 1859, he finally felt he had the manpower to do it. On October 16,
his 21-man army overran an armory in Harpers Ferry, in what is now West Virginia. Brown planned
to spark a slave uprising. Instead, his faux army found itself being steam-rollered by
Robert E. Lee's actual one.
According to History, Brown was tried for treason against the state of Virginia and, despite making
some powerful speeches attacking slavery, was convicted and hanged on December 2. His follower
Aaron Dwight Stevens was hanged for the same raid three months later. Their deaths utterly
exploded the issue of abolition, turning what had been simmering tension between North and
South into a boiling cauldron of mutual resentment. It's likely not a coincidence that civil war
erupted just 13 months after Stevens was hanged.
WILLIAM MUMFORD FAILS AT TEARING DOWN THE FLAG
The sight of someone tearing down the Stars and Stripes in the here and now can be enough to spark a riot.
But in the middle of the Civil War? New Orleans gambler William Mumford found out the hard way what
happens back in 1862. Shortly after Union soldiers entered his city and raised their flag, it was torn down
and replaced by the Confederate one. Interestingly, no one knows if Mumford was actually one of those
who tore the flag down, but his fate was sealed regardless. In May 1862, the pro-South Daily Picayune
named Mumford as the flag thief and claimed he "deserve(d) great credit." The Union army disagreed.
Word of the article got to General Benjamin Butler, who promptly ordered Mumford arrested and hanged
for treason. This being war, there was no trial. Mumford was dragged, protesting his innocence, to a gallows
near the U.S. Mint and executed without delay. His death so shocked Southern society that
Confederate President Jefferson Davis proclaimed Butler should be hanged in turn if ever captured.
That, uh, didn't happen.
THE FIRST WOMAN THE GOVERNMENT HANGED
Mary Elizabeth Jenkins Surratt may not be a household name, but she's got two good claims to fame.
She's the first woman to ever be convicted of treason in the U.S., and the first woman the federal
government executed (via ThoughtCo). A boarding house owner in the mid-19th century, Surratt made
the fateful decision to get involved in one of the grandest conspiracies of her time. She was one of
the four people who helped John Wilkes Booth pull off the assassination of Abraham Lincoln.
Surratt's actual role is murky. History says "it is believed" that Booth hatched his assassination scheme
in her boarding house, but it's also possible he never told her about it. Regardless, Surratt was linked
to Booth via her husband and was arrested along with three other conspirators. They were tried before
a military tribunal and all hanged within three months of Lincoln's death. Interestingly, because the other
three could be linked to the conspiracy, they were hanged for more concrete charges like murder.
Only Mary Surratt was convicted of treason.
WALTER ALLEN BECOMES WEST VIRGINIA'S FALL GUY
The Battle of Blair Mountain is the closest the U.S. came to a civil war in the 20th century.
In late August 1921, an armed standoff between union miners (above: random union miner) and
company strike busters in West Virginia escalated into a full-on battle that lasted over a week,
involved machine guns and aerial bombardment, and killed up to 100 people (via History).
When the dust settled, the union miners were the ones on the losing side, and West Virginia came
down on them, hard.
Over 1,000 miners surrendered to the army, and the state selected a few to absolutely throw the
book at. Two were tried with treason, and one guy, a miner named Walter Allen, became the first
person since the Civil War era to be convicted of it. According to When Miners March, a history of
the uprising, Allen was sentenced to ten years but was allowed to lodge an appeal. He duly did,
was granted bail, paid it, and then simply vanished. It's been speculated he no longer trusted the
state to deliver justice and so went into hiding. As a result, his conviction was never overturned.
His appeal is still on file with the state Supreme Court, presumably on the off chance that he
stumbles out of a time machine one day and decides to resume his case.
MAX HANS HAUPT: THE SINS OF THE SON
Herbert Hans Haupt (above) was a fully paid-up, "blood and soil," "heil the fatherland" Nazi.
In 1942 he was one of a group of pro-German defectors who boarded a U-boat to America and landed
on the east coast determined to commit sabotage. Given SS training, explosives, and stacks of U.S. dollars,
the eight saboteur-defectors were all determined to cause chaos. They were also all bumbling idiots.
Before they could carry out a single act of sabotage, all eight were arrested. Shortly after, the six who
didn't cooperate with investigators were sent to the electric chair (via History Net).
It wasn't only the saboteurs who were arrested. Two of them had received support from friends and
relatives in the U.S. One man, Anthony Cramer, who had unwittingly stored money for the group,
was convicted of treason but then had his conviction overturned on appeal. No such luck for
Herbert Hans Haupt's dad, Max. Max Hans Haupt's treason conviction was upheld, and he was sentenced
to life in prison. He was finally released in 1957 and deported to West Germany.
MARTIN JAMES MONTI DEFECTS TO THE OBVIOUSLY LOSING SIDE
American history is littered with guys who defected with unbelievable bad timing. Benedict Arnold
jumped ship only when the British were already losing like massive losers. Michael Peri attempted
to defect to East Germany just ten months before the Berlin Wall fell. And then we have
Martin James Monti. A half-German, half-Italian Air Force pilot in World War II, Monti thought the
end of Hitler's Reich would mean a global Communist victory. So he stole a plane and defected to
fascist Italy in late 1944. Barely nine months later, Italy's last fascist enclave had surrendered and
Monti was under arrest.
Incredibly, no one realized he'd defected. They just thought he'd stolen a plane and deserted,
so that's what they charged him with. Truman even commuted Monti's sentence in 1946 on the condition
he rejoin the Air Force (via History Net). It wasn't until the Washington Post looked into Monti's time
in Italy and discovered he'd joined the SS that the truth came out. Monti was arrested again and
pleaded guilty to treason in 1949. He was sentenced to 25 years.
This time, he served 11 before anyone let him out again.